Should I open a Roth IRA or stick with my HYSA for long-term savings?

  • This topic is empty.
Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #112351 Reply
    Lee

      Sorry !my question is do I need to open a roth IRA or can I continue to use my HYSA for long term savings?
      Just started The Simple Path to Wealth—thanks to everyone who recommended it!

      I’m currently opening a Fidelity brokerage account. Do I also need to open a Roth IRA, or is the brokerage account enough?

      What are the pros and cons of each option, and are there advantages to having both?

      In the future, if I decide to sell, withdraw, or trade from my brokerage account, how can I avoid taxes and penalties? Does a Roth IRA help with that?

      Also, is VOO a good investment choice, and what other options should I consider?

      #112352 Reply
      Christopher

        Take it slowly. Tax rules in this space can get complex. It’s also tempting to avoid taxes at all costs, but that’s usually not the optimal plan.

        Having both a Roth and Traditional IRA is a good idea – they cost nothing to open, so getting it all done at once is a nice way to get all your options set up at once.

        IRAs are tax sheltered, but there are differences in when they’re appropriate to use mainly related to your current and expected future tax situation.

        Money in an IRA is often penalized if you access it before you’re 59 1/2 years old (money you’ve contributed to a Roth is available whenever you want, but anything it’s earned is not).

        The rules are weird if you’re just starting out, which is why I recommend starting slowly.

        Tax treatment is a tricky subject too. Trading in an IRA has no immediate tax implications. Withdraws can though. For a regular taxable brokerage, withdraws aren’t taxable, but dividends and sales can be (whether or not you ever withdraw the money).

        Even if you sell and withdraw money, the tax liability is often pretty low compared to earned income, so a taxable brokerage is a nice place to invest for money you’ll want to use before 59 1/2.

        Strategies to access IRA funds before that age, and without penalties, also exist, but it can get complicated.

        VOO is a good ETF for road stocks, which are usually good for long term investing (money you don’t need to use for a decade or so). So is VTI.

        Just use one or the other though, there’s no need to hold both most of the time (they overlap a lot).

        #112353 Reply
        Kenny

          Roth and high yield savings accounts are for completely different things. Savings for savings like emergency fund, home repair, insurance that is due every six months to a year.

          Roth is you invest money and it grows tax free and you can take the money out tax free.

          This assumes you qualify for a Roth IRA account. As others said, finish the book. It covers the details.

          #112354 Reply
          Endri

            That book is so good, that basically if you read the first page of his summoned advice and you follow it, you don’t need to read anything about personal finance ever again and you will be rich.

            Also, it has life advice too.

            #112355 Reply
            Elizabeth

              A Roth account is a retirement savings vehicle that has special advantages and protections.

              There are limits about how much you can add to this per year. It can hold ETFs, stocks, mutual unds, etc.

              A brokerage account can have similar investments as a Roth, but it’s not tax advantaged in the same way but has less restrictions.

              #112356 Reply
              Ernest

                “In the future, if I decide to sell, withdraw, or trade from my brokerage account, how can I avoid taxes and penalties? Does a Roth IRA help with that?” Yes.

                That’s exactly why Roth accounts exists.

                While your HYSA and taxable brokerage accounts are subject to federal and state taxes – Roths are exempt.

              Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
              Reply To: Should I open a Roth IRA or stick with my HYSA for long-term savings?
              Your information:




              Spread the love